The
second album from the freshly reformed Europe coming
a couple of years after the strong ‘Start From The Dark’
an album that was good straight from the off and boded well for a
bright future. So it was some excitement when I popped “Secret
Society” into my cd player for the first time, pressed play
and found myself not getting that excited and finding it increasingly
difficult to maintain any enthusiasm for the album the further it went
on. Since this initial first spin I have given it numerous listens
that extend into double digits and it still does nothing for me.
The opening title track
starts promisingly enough but then feels the need to take the modern
rock approach too far with a total unnecessary breakdown in the middle
which ruins the song. “Always The Pretender”
has a fairly good riff but to repeat it over and over gets monotonous
quickly and the chorus is a total none starter. Joey Tempest then
informs us that “Love Is Not The Enemy” which
is home to some detuned Norum riffery over which Tempest feels the
need to try and sound like Scott Weiland with way too much mono effect
on his vocals. Luckily the chorus is good, although reminiscent of the
material on the previous album but the song basically just smells like
Europe trying to be someone else and Norum sounds like he is mailing
it in for the solo.
“Wish I
Could Believe” sees the band seemingly have injected a
concoction of Soundgarden (c. Superunknown) and Core era Stone Temple
Pilots, both good albums but NOT what I want to hear from these
Scandinavian rockers. To say it sounds like the band realising their
sound of old doesn’t get radio play anymore so they will go with what
stands a chance is close to the bone here. “Let The
Children Play” begins with a half-cocked wah riff from
Norum before the band kicks in and the Seattle comparisons heard on
the last song raise their head again sadly. “Human After
All” begins promisingly enough with keyboard
orchestrations before another Norum down tuned riff brings back to
the, by now, familiar sound of this album and it’s a song that
ultimately washes itself over you unnoticed. This trend continues
again for “The Getaway Plan” which really
begins to show the stale formula of this album for what it is. Luckily
just when I had about given up all hope of getting a decent song the
tender “A Mother’s Son” comes along, led by
piano and restraint orchestration which grows in a very natural way.
Again Norum feels the need to down-tune for the chorus (this is not a
Creed album, Mr Norum!) but this doesn’t spoil the track.
“Forever
Travelling” is another semi decent track which again
thanks to the more melodic nature of it reaps the benefits. Tempest’s
voice is good here, clear and unaffected by any studio trickery (save
for the odd harmony backing) and Norum also manages to reel the
detuned riffery in - a highlight. The title “Brave And
Beautiful Soul” gives a clue that this is likely to be
another dreary modern rocker and it doesn’t disappoint in that sense.
I get the impression the band are going for a U2 vibe, all well and
good if you happen to be U2, but as well all know that is wasn’t
Europe is about. The album closes with “Devil Sings The
Blues” which kicks off with a good acoustic bluesy lick
before building and its probably the highlight of the album with
Norum’s best solo too showcasing his great touch and phrasing which,
sadly, is all too lacking from the majority of solo sections on the
album.
I really wanted to like
this album; in fact I was sure I would after “Start From The Dark”.
But it has failed to make an impression on me save for a couple of
tracks after numerous repeated spins. I have persevered with it as I
thought I should like this, but the simple fact is I don’t. As
mentioned in the track by track analysis the problem is too many down
tuned riffs (save them for the solo albums John) which loose their
impact after a while. Also there are too many examples of the band
trying to sound like other bands which make those songs sound forced.
The tracks that stand out sound like “Europe” tracks with a natural
feel and delivery. Sonically the album is very well produced (arguably
better than “Start From The Dark”) but a good production does little
to save songs that aren’t happening and unfortunately for the most
part these songs aren’t.
Rating – 45%